Skip to main content

Paper: WEBQUESTIONS paper (Semantic Parsing on Freebase from Question-Answer Pairs), authored by Berant et al. (2013)

The WEBQUESTIONS paper (Semantic Parsing on Freebase from Question-Answer Pairs), authored by Berant et al. (2013) and presented at EMNLP, introduced a benchmark dataset and a semantic parsing method for answering open-domain questions using Freebase, a large-scale knowledge base (KB). Below is a structured breakdown of the paper:

1. Key Contributions

  1. Dataset Introduction:

    • Released WEBQUESTIONS, a dataset of 3,778 question-answer pairs (later expanded to 5,810) collected using Google Suggest API.

    • Questions are natural language queries (e.g., "Where was Einstein born?"), paired with answers from Freebase.

  2. Task Definition:

    • Goal: Map natural language questions to Freebase queries (logical forms) to retrieve answers.

    • Challenge: Freebase contains ~2B facts, making manual query construction infeasible.

  3. Methodology:

    • Proposed a log-linear semantic parser that learns to map questions to Freebase queries (using lambda calculus) from weak supervision (only QA pairs, not logical forms).

    • Leveraged feature-based learning (e.g., lexical, syntactic, KB-based features).

2. Semantic Parsing Approach

Pipeline

  1. Candidate Generation:

    • For each question, generate possible Freebase entities (e.g., "Einstein" → m.0b3fp9).

    • Use n-gram matching and alias detection (Freebase’s /type/object/key).

  2. Query Construction:

    • Build logical forms (lambda-DCS expressions) like:

      Copy
      (lambda x (PlaceOfBirth (Person "Einstein")) → Returns "Ulm, Germany".

    • Supports compositionality (e.g., "Who directed Inception?" → (Film Director "Inception")).

  3. Learning & Inference:

    • Training: Learn feature weights using beam search + perceptron.

    • Features:

      • Lexical (question words + Freebase predicates).

      • Compositional (how predicates combine).

      • KB-coverage (answer recall).

  4. Answer Extraction:

    • Execute the top-ranked logical form on Freebase to retrieve answers.

3. Key Innovations

  • Weak Supervision: Learned from QA pairs alone, without annotated logical forms.

  • Lambda-DCS: A simplified query language for Freebase, enabling efficient parsing.

  • Feature Engineering: Combined linguistic and KB-structure features.

4. Results & Impact

  • Achieved 39.9% F1 on WEBQUESTIONS (vs. 30.4% for IR baselines).

  • Limitations:

    • Struggled with complex questions (multi-hop, aggregation).

    • Dependency on Freebase (deprecated in 2016).

  • Legacy:

    • Pioneered KBQA (Knowledge-Based Question Answering).

    • Inspired later work like GraphQuery (Yih et al., 2015) and neural semantic parsers.

5. Dataset Details

StatisticValue
# Questions3,778 (train) + 2,032 (test)
Avg. Question Length4.5 words
Answer SourcesFreebase (entities, relations)
Example Question"Who founded Microsoft?" → ["Bill Gates", "Paul Allen"]

6. Comparison with Later Work

AspectWEBQUESTIONS (2013)Modern KBQA (e.g., SPARQL, BERT-based)
SupervisionWeak (QA pairs)Strong (annotated queries) / Zero-shot
KBFreebaseWikidata, DBPedia, Custom KGs
ModelLog-linear parserNeural models (Transformers, GNNs)
ComplexitySingle-relationMulti-hop, temporal, compositional

7. Code Example (Simplified Lambda-DCS Query)

python
Copy
# Pseudo-code for "Where was Einstein born?"
query = {
  "entity": "Albert_Einstein",
  "relation": "PlaceOfBirth",
  "target": "?city"
}
# Freebase equivalent: (PlaceOfBirth (Person "Albert_Einstein"))

8. Why This Paper Matters

  • Foundational Work: First large-scale QA dataset tied to Freebase.

  • Paradigm Shift: Showed semantic parsing could be learned without logical form annotations.

  • Benchmark: WEBQUESTIONS remains a standard evaluation set for KBQA.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Simple Linear Regression - and Related Regression Loss Functions

Today's Topics: a. Regression Algorithms  b. Outliers - Explained in Simple Terms c. Common Regression Metrics Explained d. Overfitting and Underfitting e. How are Linear and Non Linear Regression Algorithms used in Neural Networks [Future study topics] Regression Algorithms Regression algorithms are a category of machine learning methods used to predict a continuous numerical value. Linear regression is a simple, powerful, and interpretable algorithm for this type of problem. Quick Example: These are the scores of students vs. the hours they spent studying. Looking at this dataset of student scores and their corresponding study hours, can we determine what score someone might achieve after studying for a random number of hours? Example: From the graph, we can estimate that 4 hours of daily study would result in a score near 80. It is a simple example, but for more complex tasks the underlying concept will be similar. If you understand this graph, you will understand this blog. Sim...
Post a Comment
Read more

What problems can AI Neural Networks solve

How does AI Neural Networks solve Problems? What problems can AI Neural Networks solve? Based on effectiveness and common usage, here's the ranking from best to least suitable for neural networks (Classification Problems, Regression Problems and Optimization Problems.) But first some Math, background and related topics as how the Neural Network Learn by training (Supervised Learning and Unsupervised Learning.)  Background Note - Mathematical Precision vs. Practical AI Solutions. Math can solve all these problems with very accurate results. While Math can theoretically solve classification, regression, and optimization problems with perfect accuracy, such calculations often require impractical amounts of time—hours, days, or even years for complex real-world scenarios. In practice, we rarely need absolute precision; instead, we need actionable results quickly enough to make timely decisions. Neural networks excel at this trade-off, providing "good enough" solutions in seco...
Post a Comment
Read more

Activation Functions in Neural Networks

  A Guide to Activation Functions in Neural Networks 🧠 Question: Without activation function can a neural network with many layers be non-linear? Answer: Provided at the end of this document. Activation functions are a crucial component of neural networks. Their primary purpose is to introduce non-linearity , which allows the network to learn the complex, winding patterns found in real-world data. Without them, a neural network, no matter how deep, would just be a simple linear model. In the diagram below the f is the activation function that receives input and send output to next layers. Commonly used activation functions. 1. Sigmoid Function 2. Tanh (Hyperbolic Tangent) 3. ReLU (Rectified Linear Unit - Like an Electronic Diode) 4. Leaky ReLU & PReLU 5. ELU (Exponential Linear Unit) 6. Softmax 7. GELU, Swish, and SiLU 1. Sigmoid Function                       The classic "S-curve," Sigmoid squashes any input value t...
Post a Comment
Read more